Eva Kotátková: A Storyteller’s Inadequacy | Review
Modern Art Oxford | 30 November 2013 – 2 February 2014
Kotátková started school in 1989, in newly post-communist Prague. This was a moment of unlearning and re-learning; a seismic shift in accepted societal conventions. For Kotátková, it was also the moment of induction into the acceptable behaviours of the educational establishment; the first (or arguably second, after the institution of the family unit) of many institutions to follow, each in turn instilling our compliance of society’s restrictions.
Much of her previous work drew on these early experiences of the school environment. In her salient installation Re-education Machine (2011), Kotátková re-imagines the tools of education, such as a 1960s Czechoslovakian printing press, as instruments of torture and imprisonment, or her video Sit Straight (2008), in which tools to discipline and instruct become pain-inducing. These works explore the ways in which a supposedly enlightening system is equally a vehicle for indoctrination, subjected to mechanisms that, according to the artist, ‘serve only to unify communication patterns and force opinions; allocating specific social norms to people’. Kotátková has since continued to examine an array of different institutions and disciplinary systems, such as psychiatric hospitals and prisons, considering the ways in which each repress and manipulate behavior.
Her work at Modern Art Oxford, however, takes a bold step away from a previously distanced relationship with her audience. The welded structures sit alongside more familiar and homely objects – a worn carpet, a selection of scuffed books, an old door – all laid out upon a blackboard stage, shaped in a cross-section of a head, from the nasal cavity down to throat. Kotátková calls this a ‘speech organ’, severing the act of speaking from personality or facial expression. The fading traces of performers’ movements are marked out in chalk – a literal depiction of their ‘going through the motions’. The performer lets a steel ring drop to the floor; its echo reverberates around the room. She is indifferent and still, once again. There is a Kafkaesque futility in her attempts to make sense of her surroundings, to articulate herself, through equally absurd actions. These repetitive, awkward and – despite their peculiarity – understated exchanges between object, action and actor mediate a bleak outlook on the internalized struggle of our everyday condition. It’s a struggle that is unglorified, banal.
This sense of internal monologue is as important to the experience of the work as it is its narrative. You cannot help but be drawn into a type of metafiction: we keep up our act as audience as much as the performer does hers, politely complying with the conventions of the gallery space. The exhibition’s linchpin is in the middle gallery, where a lecture performance explores the topic of radical narration, based on a script written by
Elsewhere, carefully presented tableaux in vitrines, meticulously cut pictures collaged from old magazines and textbooks; children playing, housewives at work, animals, odd limbs, all tied together with Kotátková’s characteristically intrusive white rope lines. A pin spears through the eye of a pelican, clasping it in place. There is an indifference in the cruelty and manipulation that she creates in these vitrines, perhaps a quiet acceptance of its omnipotence throughout society’s make-up.
To return to the analogy of S&M, its namesake the Marquis de Sade is an apt starting point for understanding the complex narratives of societal control at play in Kotátková’s work. An advocate of extreme freedom, De Sade rejected all of the mechanisms of control that Kotátková’s work addresses. He led a life true to his philosophy, and was inevitably imprisoned. It is exactly this impotence that ‘The Storyteller’s Inadequacy’ portrays; the struggle to articulate independent thought and freewill, and then moreover, the struggle to act on that articulation. Whilst Kotátková past work has dealt with specific types of institutionalization, this exhibition can be read from a greater, and more potent, perspective. It confronts a greater malady throughout society; where we are all molded and dependent on the very conventions that hinder our ability to think, speak and act independently. Here, Kotátková suggests that even that which we take for granted – our ability to speak, to articulate – is thrown into question when considering our societal conditioning.